| 1 | Bleacher Creatures WWE Limited Edition Plush Limited Run Collector Editions Bleacher Creatures periodically releases limited edition WWE plush in smaller print runs with alternate colorways or special packaging — the most coveted collector editions in the lineup. | 10 inches | Limited Edition Collector Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $27–$34 |
| 2 | WWE Hall of Fame Commemorative Plush Set Annual HOF Inductee Plush Bundle Annual WWE Hall of Fame commemorative plush set released each WrestleMania season featuring that year's Hall of Fame inductee class. | 10 inches each | Annual HOF Collector Set | Bleacher Creatures / WWE Shop | $54–$84 |
| 3 | Signed WWE Superstar Plush — Authenticated Autographed Collector Premium WWE superstars occasionally sign Bleacher Creatures plush at fan conventions and on WWE.com — authenticated signed plush are among the most valuable WWE plush collectibles. | 10 inches | Autographed Premium Collector Plush | Bleacher Creatures (Signed) | $75–$300+ |
| 4 | WWE Prototype Sample Plush Production Sample — Ultra Rare Unreleased production prototype WWE plush samples occasionally surface on collector markets — these pre-production items are among the rarest WWE plush collectibles. | Various | Production Prototype — Ultra Rare | Bleacher Creatures Prototype | $150–$500+ |
| 5 | WWE Phenom Gallery Art Plush Collaboration Premium Art Series Plush Phenom Gallery x Bleacher Creatures limited art collaboration plush — premium collector editions combining gallery-quality art design with the Bleacher Creatures plush format. | 10 inches | Art Collaboration Collector Plush | Phenom Gallery x Bleacher Creatures | $34–$54 |
| 6 | WWE WrestleMania 42 Exclusive Collector Plush Set Event Exclusive — Las Vegas WWE WrestleMania 42 venue-exclusive plush set available only at Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas on April 18–19, 2026 — featuring WM42-specific packaging and design. | 10 inches | Event Exclusive Collector Plush | Bleacher Creatures / WWE Shop | $34–$54 |
| 7 | WWE Retirement / Final Match Commemorative Plush Career Farewell Collector Edition Special retirement and final match commemorative plush editions released to mark career-ending moments — John Cena farewell editions are among the most anticipated collector plush of 2025–2026. | 10 inches | Career Farewell Collector Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $29–$39 |
| 8 | WWE Title Change Commemorative Plush Championship Moment Edition Limited commemorative plush released to mark specific championship title changes — typically featuring the winning superstar in their title-winning ring gear. | 10 inches | Championship Moment Collector Plush | Bleacher Creatures / WWE Shop | $27–$34 |
| 9 | WWE Custom Display Case for Plush Collection Collector Display Accessory An officially licensed WWE acrylic display case designed to protect and showcase a full Bleacher Creatures plush collection — the essential accessory for serious collectors. | Display case | Collector Display Accessory | WWE Official Shop | $39–$79 |
| 10 | WWE Complete Series Collector Bundle Full Wave Collector Set Complete series collector bundles available during Bleacher Creatures wave releases — buying the full wave typically includes a discount and exclusive bundle packaging. | 10 inches each | Full Wave Collector Bundle | Bleacher Creatures | $129–$199 |