| 1 | Dark Match: Paul Roma vs. Brooklyn Brawler Result: Paul Roma wins | Time: 6:00 | Shane McMahon served as referee The pre-show dark match saw Paul Roma defeat the Brooklyn Brawler in six minutes, with a young Shane McMahon serving as the referee — a noteworthy cameo from the future WWE Chairman's son. | 6:00 | Paul Roma wins | Shane McMahon |
| 2 | Rick Martel vs. Koko B. Ware Result: Martel wins by submission (Arrogance/Boston Crab) | Time: 3:51 Rick 'The Model' Martel opened the PPV card with a clean submission victory over Koko B. Ware, further establishing his new arrogant heel character. | 3:51 | Rick Martel wins by submission | — |
| 3 | Demolition vs. Colossal Connection — WWF Tag Team Championship Result: TITLE CHANGE — Demolition wins | Time: 9:30 Demolition won the WWF Tag Team Championship when Haku accidentally super-kicked André. Post-match, André turned babyface — slapping Bobby Heenan and Haku in an emotional farewell to the Heenan Family. | 9:30 | NEW CHAMPIONS — Demolition wins | — |
| 4 | Earthquake vs. Hercules Result: Earthquake wins by pinfall | Time: 4:52 Earthquake dominated and pinned Hercules, then hit two post-match splashes to further establish himself as the WWF's next monster heel. | 4:52 | Earthquake wins by pinfall | — |
| 5 | Brutus Beefcake vs. Mr. Perfect Result: Beefcake wins by pinfall | Time: 7:48 Brutus Beefcake scored the victory billed as Mr. Perfect's first pinfall loss in the WWF. Post-match, Beefcake put The Genius to sleep and cut his hair. | 7:48 | Beefcake wins by pinfall | — |
| 6 | Roddy Piper vs. Bad News Brown Result: Double Countout | Time: 6:48 Neither man could claim victory after both brawled to the arena floor and failed to beat the referee's count. The match was later removed from Peacock streaming in 2021 due to Piper's controversial half-black face paint. | 6:48 | Double Countout | — |
| 7 | Hart Foundation vs. Bolsheviks Result: Hart Foundation wins by pinfall | Time: 0:19 The shortest match in WrestleMania history. The Bolsheviks attempted the Soviet anthem after the bell — Hart Foundation attacked and pinned them in 19 seconds. | 0:19 | Hart Foundation wins | — |
| 8 | The Barbarian vs. Tito Santana Result: Barbarian wins by pinfall | Time: 4:33 The Barbarian defeated Tito Santana in a straightforward singles showcase with Bobby Heenan at ringside. | 4:33 | The Barbarian wins by pinfall | — |
| 9 | Dusty Rhodes and Sapphire vs. Randy Savage and Queen Sherri Result: Rhodes and Sapphire win | Time: 7:44 Dusty Rhodes and Sapphire won the mixed tag match with Miss Elizabeth appearing as a surprise supporter. Sapphire pinned Sherri for the victory. | 7:44 | Dusty Rhodes and Sapphire win | — |
| 10 | Orient Express vs. The Rockers Result: Orient Express win by count-out | Time: 7:36 Mr. Fuji threw salt into Marty Jannetty's eyes on the arena floor, causing a count-out loss for The Rockers in the best undercard athletic contest of the night. | 7:36 | Orient Express win by count-out | — |
| 11 | Jim Duggan vs. Dino Bravo Result: Duggan wins by pinfall | Time: 4:15 Duggan hit Bravo with his 2x4 for the pin. Earthquake attacked Duggan post-match with two splashes. | 4:15 | Duggan wins by pinfall | — |
| 12 | Ted DiBiase vs. Jake Roberts — Million Dollar Championship Result: DiBiase wins by count-out | Time: 11:53 DiBiase won by count-out after Virgil distracted Roberts. Post-match, Roberts DDT'd DiBiase and distributed his $100 bills to ringside fans including actress Mary Tyler Moore. | 11:53 | DiBiase wins by count-out | — |
| 13 | Big Boss Man vs. Akeem Result: Boss Man wins by pinfall | Time: approx. 1:50 Big Boss Man quickly disposed of his former Twin Towers partner Akeem with the Sidewalk Slam. | approx. 1:50 | Big Boss Man wins by pinfall | — |
| 14 | Rick Rude vs. Jimmy Snuka Result: Rude wins by pinfall | Time: approx. 3:00 Rick Rude defeated the legendary Superfly Snuka in a brief showcase match ahead of his post-WM6 programme with the new WWF Champion. | approx. 3:00 | Rude wins by pinfall | — |
| 15 | Ultimate Warrior vs. Hulk Hogan — Winner Takes All Result: TITLE CHANGE — Warrior wins both championships | Time: 22:03 The Ultimate Warrior defeated Hulk Hogan to win both the WWF World Heavyweight Championship and the WWF Intercontinental Championship simultaneously — the most historic title change in WrestleMania history to that point. | 22:03 | NEW CHAMPION — Ultimate Warrior wins both titles | — |