| 1 | Bret Hart — BABYFACE Respected Technical Champion — Underdog vs. Monster Bret Hart was a full babyface at WM9 — the respected technical wrestler defending his WWF Championship against the unstoppable monster heel Yokozuna. | BABYFACE | Technical excellence WWF Champion — underdog vs. monster |
| 2 | Hulk Hogan — BABYFACE Returning American Hero Hulk Hogan was a babyface at WM9 — the returning American hero teaming with Beefcake against Money Inc. and eventually winning the WWF title impromptu. | BABYFACE | Returning American hero — crowd favorite |
| 3 | Yokozuna — HEEL Unstoppable Monster Champion Yokozuna was the primary monster heel of WM9 — the 500-pound challenger and eventual champion who used Mr. Fuji's salt to win the WWF title. | HEEL (monster) | Unstoppable foreign monster |
| 4 | The Undertaker — HEEL (Transitioning) Supernatural Dark Character — Still Technically Heel The Undertaker was technically a heel at WM9 — though his supernatural character was increasingly attracting babyface crowd reactions, his official alignment was still heel. | HEEL (but transitioning to babyface crowd reactions) | — |
| 5 | Shawn Michaels — HEEL Cowardly IC Champion — Luna Vachon's Client Shawn Michaels was a full heel IC Champion at WM9 — using Luna Vachon and count-out tactics to retain the Intercontinental Championship. | HEEL | Cowardly IC Champion — retained via count-out |
| 6 | Razor Ramon — HEEL The Bad Guy — Still a Villain at WM9 Razor Ramon was officially a heel at WM9 — though his 'Bad Guy' persona was generating growing crowd appreciation that would eventually lead to his babyface turn. | HEEL (transitioning to fan favorite) | The Bad Guy — Cuban heel |
| 7 | Money Inc. — HEEL Villainous Corporate Tag Champions Money Inc. (Ted DiBiase and IRS) were full heels at WM9 — the corporate greed characters defending the WWF Tag Team Championship against the fan-favourite Mega-Maniacs. | HEEL | Corporate greed — Million Dollar Man and Irwin R. Schyster |
| 8 | Doink the Clown — HEEL Evil Clown Character — Villainous Trickster Doink the Clown (Matt Borne) was a full heel at WM9 — the evil clown character who used a second Doink to defeat the sympathetic babyface Crush. | HEEL | Evil clown — vicious trickster |
| 9 | Tatanka — BABYFACE Native American Undefeated Streak Tatanka was a full babyface at WM9 — a proud Native American character in the midst of a long undefeated streak, with Sensational Sherri in his corner after turning on Shawn Michaels. | BABYFACE | Native American — long undefeated streak |
| 10 | Steiner Brothers — BABYFACE Fan Favourite Power Tag Team The Steiner Brothers (Rick and Scott) were full babyfaces at WM9 — fan-favourite power tag team defeating the heel Headshrinkers in WM9's best match. | BABYFACE | Power tag team — athletic collegiate wrestling style |