| 1 | Randy Savage — WWE Hall of Famer 2015 Posthumous — WM5 WWF Champion Who Lost Title Randy Savage was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2015 posthumously — the defending WWF Champion who lost his title to Hulk Hogan at WM5's Mega Powers Explode main event. | 2,015 | Defending WWF Champion — lost title to Hogan | true |
| 2 | Hulk Hogan — WWE Hall of Famer 2005 WM5 — Won Second WWF Championship Hulk Hogan was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2005 — winning his second WWF Championship at WM5's main event against Randy Savage. | 2,005 | Main Event — Won WWF Championship (2nd reign) | — |
| 3 | Shawn Michaels — WWE Hall of Famer 2011 WM5 Debut — Mr. WrestleMania's First Appearance Shawn Michaels was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2011 — making his WM debut at WM5 as part of The Rockers, beginning the greatest WM career in history. | 2,011 | WM Debut — The Rockers (loss to Twin Towers) | — |
| 4 | Bret Hart — WWE Hall of Famer 2006 WM5 Hart Foundation Win Over Rhythm & Blues Bret Hart was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2006 — competing with The Hart Foundation at WM5 in their grudge win over Rhythm & Blues (Honky Tonk Man and Greg Valentine). | 2,006 | Hart Foundation — Tag Match win over Rhythm & Blues | — |
| 5 | Bobby Heenan — WWE Hall of Famer 2004 Managed 4 Clients AND Competed — WM5 Bobby Heenan was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2004 — uniquely managing four separate clients AND competing himself at WM5. | 2,004 | Managed King Haku, Rude, Busters, Andre + Lost to Red Roo... | — |
| 6 | Arn Anderson — WWE Hall of Famer 2012 Class of 2012 (Four Horsemen) — Brain Busters WM5 Debut Arn Anderson was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame as part of The Four Horsemen in 2012 — making his WM debut at WM5 as part of The Brain Busters. | 2,012 | Brain Busters WM Debut — Win over Strike Force | — |
| 7 | Tully Blanchard — WWE Hall of Famer 2012 Class of 2012 (Four Horsemen) — Brain Busters WM5 Debut Tully Blanchard was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame as part of The Four Horsemen in 2012 — making his WM debut at WM5 as part of The Brain Busters with Arn Anderson. | 2,012 | Brain Busters WM Debut — Win over Strike Force | — |
| 8 | Mr. Perfect (Curt Hennig) — WWE Hall of Famer 2007 Posthumous — Mr. Perfect WM5 Debut Win Curt Hennig was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame posthumously in 2007 — debuting his Mr. Perfect character at WM5 with a win over Owen Hart (as Blue Blazer). | 2,007 | Mr. Perfect WM Debut — Win over Blue Blazer (Owen Hart) | true |
| 9 | Jim Neidhart — WWE Hall of Famer 2019 Class of 2019 (Hart Foundation) — WM5 Tag Win Jim Neidhart was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame as part of The Hart Foundation in 2019 — competing with Bret Hart in The Hart Foundation's WM5 grudge win over Rhythm & Blues. | 2,019 | Hart Foundation — Tag Win over Rhythm & Blues | — |
| 10 | Andre the Giant — WWE Hall of Famer 1993 Inaugural HOF Inductee — WM5 Jake Roberts Match Andre the Giant was the inaugural WWE Hall of Fame inductee in 1993 — competing in his final WrestleMania appearance at WM5 against Jake Roberts with Big John Studd as special referee. | 1,993 | Match vs. Jake Roberts — DQ loss (final WM appearance) | — |