| 1 | Randy Savage — WWE Hall of Famer 2015 Posthumous Induction — Main Event Champion Randy Savage was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2015 (posthumously, having passed away on May 20, 2011) — the greatest performer at WM4 who won four matches in one night to become WWF Champion. | Class of 2015 | 2,015 | Main Event — Won WWF Championship (4 matches) | true |
| 2 | Hulk Hogan — WWE Hall of Famer 2005 Inducted by Sylvester Stallone Hulk Hogan was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2005 — participating in WM4's quarter-final against Andre the Giant before appearing ringside in the championship final. | Class of 2005 | 2,005 | Quarter Final participant + main event ringside | — |
| 3 | Andre the Giant — WWE Hall of Famer 1993 Inaugural Inductee — Quarter Final Andre the Giant was the inaugural WWE Hall of Fame inductee in 1993 — competing in WM4's quarter-final before being eliminated alongside Hogan via double DQ and then serving ringside for DiBiase's matches. | Inaugural Inductee | 1,993 | Quarter Final participant + DiBiase ringside | true |
| 4 | Bret Hart — WWE Hall of Famer 2006 The Hitman — Battle Royal Runner-Up Bret Hart was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2006 — participating in WM4's opening Battle Royal where he was the final man eliminated by Bad News Brown. | Class of 2006 | 2,006 | Battle Royal — Final eliminated (by Bad News Brown) | — |
| 5 | Bobby Heenan — WWE Hall of Famer 2004 The Brain — Manager AND Competitor Bobby Heenan was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2004 — uniquely participating at WM4 as both manager (Andre, Rude) and in-ring competitor (six-man tag). | Class of 2004 | 2,004 | Manager (Andre + Rude) + In-Ring Competitor (Six-Man Tag) | — |
| 6 | Tito Santana — WWE Hall of Famer 2004 Class of 2004 — Strike Force Tag Champion Tito Santana was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2004 — competing as part of Strike Force in the WM4 WWF Tag Team Championship match against Demolition. | Class of 2004 | 2,004 | Strike Force — Tag Championship Match (lost title to Demo... | — |
| 7 | Ricky Steamboat — WWE Hall of Famer 2009 Class of 2009 — Tournament First Round Ricky Steamboat was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2009 — competing in WM4's tournament first round where he lost to Greg Valentine. | Class of 2009 | 2,009 | Tournament First Round — Lost to Greg Valentine | — |
| 8 | Hillbilly Jim — WWE Hall of Famer 2018 Class of 2018 — Battle Royal Participant Hillbilly Jim was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2018 — participating in WM4's opening 20-man Battle Royal. | Class of 2018 | 2,018 | 20-Man Battle Royal Participant | — |
| 9 | Greg Valentine — WWE Hall of Famer 2004 Class of 2004 — Tournament Quarter Final Greg Valentine was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2004 — advancing to the WM4 quarter-finals by defeating Ricky Steamboat before losing to Randy Savage. | Class of 2004 | 2,004 | Tournament — R1 win (Steamboat) + QF loss (Savage) | — |
| 10 | Donald Trump — WWE Hall of Famer 2013 Celebrity Wing — WM4 & WM5 Host Donald Trump was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2013 under the Celebrity Wing — prominently featured as the host of WM4 (and WM5) through the Trump Plaza branding. | Class of 2013 | 2,013 | Event Host — Trump Plaza branding | — |