| 1 | Randy Savage WM2 Debut 10" Plush Macho Man's First WrestleMania — IC Champion Randy Savage's WM2 WrestleMania debut 10-inch plush — the Macho Man's first WM appearance as Intercontinental Champion, retaining against George Steele at Nassau Coliseum with Miss Elizabeth at ringside. | 10 inches | WM2 Debut Commemorative Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $27.99 |
| 2 | Bret Hart WM2 Debut 10" Plush The Hitman's First WrestleMania — Battle Royal Bret Hart's WM2 WrestleMania debut 10-inch plush — The Hitman's first WM appearance in the Chicago Battle Royal where he was the final wrestler eliminated by Andre the Giant, an early chapter in the greatest career in wrestling history. | 10 inches | WM2 Debut Commemorative Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $27.99 |
| 3 | Jake Roberts WM2 Debut 10" Plush with Snake The Snake's First WrestleMania — Damien Edition Jake 'The Snake' Roberts' WM2 debut 10-inch plush complete with his snake bag Damien — celebrating his first WM appearance with a DDT victory over George Wells at Nassau Coliseum. | 10 inches + snake prop | WM2 Debut Commemorative Plush with Snake | Bleacher Creatures | $29.99 |
| 4 | Jim Neidhart WM2 Debut 10" Plush The Anvil's First WrestleMania — Battle Royal Jim 'The Anvil' Neidhart's WM2 debut 10-inch plush — the Hart Foundation powerhouse's first WM appearance in the Chicago Battle Royal alongside tag partner Bret Hart. | 10 inches | WM2 Debut Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $22.99 |
| 5 | WM2 Future Champions Debut 3-Pack Savage, Bret Hart & Jake Roberts — All Made History The WM2 Future Champions debut 3-pack — featuring three WM2 debutants who all became either WWF Champions or Hall of Famers: Randy Savage, Bret Hart, and Jake Roberts. | 10 inches each | WM2 Future Champions Debut 3-Pack | Bleacher Creatures | $69.99 |
| 6 | British Bulldogs WM2 Debut Champions 2-Pack First WrestleMania — First Title Win The British Bulldogs WM2 debut 2-pack — Dynamite Kid and Davey Boy Smith in their first WrestleMania appearance, which was also their championship-winning performance at Chicago. | 10 inches each | WM2 Debut Champion 2-Pack | Bleacher Creatures | $44.99 |
| 7 | George Steele WM2 Debut Opponent Plush The Animal — WM2 IC Title Challenger George 'The Animal' Steele's WM2 10-inch plush — the unpredictable challenger who made WrestleMania history at WM2 by being the first superstar to kick out of Randy Savage's flying elbow drop. | 10 inches | WM2 Debut Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $22.99 |
| 8 | Hercules WM2 Debut 10" Plush First WM Loss — Los Angeles Hercules' WM2 debut 10-inch plush — the powerful future Heenan Family member in his first WrestleMania appearance, losing to Ricky Steamboat in Los Angeles at WM2. | 10 inches | WM2 Debut Plush | WWE Official Shop | $22.99 |
| 9 | WM2 Debut Superstars Complete Collector's Set All WM2 Debutants in One Bundle The complete WM2 debut superstars collector's set — featuring mini plush of every superstar making their WM debut at WM2: Randy Savage, Bret Hart, Jake Roberts, Jim Neidhart, and the British Bulldogs. | Mini display versions | WM2 Debutants Collector's Set | WWE Official Shop | $69.99 |
| 10 | Randy Savage WM2 Debut Kuricha Chibi Plush Macho Man WM Debut — Chibi Style Randy Savage's WM2 debut Kuricha chibi 8-inch plush — the Macho Man in adorable chibi form celebrating his historic WrestleMania debut as Intercontinental Champion at Nassau Coliseum. | 8 inches | WM2 Debut Kuricha Chibi | Bleacher Creatures | $22.99 |