| 1 | First National PPV WrestleMania Plush — Hogan WM2 — First WM on National PPV A commemorative Hulk Hogan plush marking WrestleMania 2 as the first WrestleMania to air on the national pay-per-view market — the beginning of the most successful annual PPV franchise in history. | 10 inches | Record Commemorative Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $29.99 |
| 2 | First WM Steel Cage Match Plush — Hogan WM2 — First Steel Cage in WM History A commemorative Hulk Hogan WM2 taped-ribs plush marking the first Steel Cage match in WrestleMania history — a stipulation that has become one of the most popular in WM events since 1986. | 10 inches | Record Commemorative Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $29.99 |
| 3 | Only WM Three-Venue Commemorative Plush Set Three Cities — One Night — One WrestleMania The Only Three-Venue WrestleMania commemorative plush set — celebrating the unique fact that WM2 is the only WrestleMania ever held across three simultaneous venues in three cities. | 10 inches each | Record Commemorative Set | WWE Official Shop | $69.99 |
| 4 | Only Monday WrestleMania Plush — Hogan Monday April 7, 1986 — Unique WM Day A commemorative Hulk Hogan plush marking WM2 as the only WrestleMania held on a Monday until the two-night WM36 in 2020 — a scheduling anomaly that makes WM2 unique among 42 WrestleMania events. | 10 inches | Record Commemorative Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $27.99 |
| 5 | First WM Randy Savage Debut Commemorative Plush Macho Man's WM Debut — WM2 IC Champion A special first WM appearance commemorative Randy Savage plush — marking the Macho Man's historic WM debut as IC Champion at WM2, the beginning of one of the greatest WrestleMania careers in history. | 10 inches | WM Debut Commemorative Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $27.99 |
| 6 | First WM Bret Hart Appearance Plush The Hitman's WM Debut — WM2 Battle Royal A commemorative Bret Hart WM2 debut plush — marking the beginning of one of the greatest WrestleMania careers in history with Hart's first appearance in the Chicago Battle Royal. | 10 inches | WM Debut Commemorative Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $27.99 |
| 7 | First WM George Steele Kicked Out of Finisher Record First to Kick Out of Savage's Flying Elbow A commemorative George Steele plush marking the WM2 record of being the first wrestler ever to kick out of Randy Savage's flying elbow drop — a historic in-match feat captured at WM2. | 10 inches | Record Commemorative Plush | WWE Official Shop | $22.99 |
| 8 | WM2 Combined Three-Venue Attendance Record Plush 40,085 Combined Attendance — WM2 Record A commemorative Hulk Hogan WM2 plush with fact sheet noting the combined three-venue attendance of 40,085 fans across New York, Chicago, and Los Angeles — the unique combined attendance figure for the three-city event. | 10 inches | Attendance Record Commemorative Plush | Bleacher Creatures | $27.99 |
| 9 | WM2 $5 Million PPV Revenue Record Plush First $5M PPV Revenue WrestleMania A commemorative plush marking WM2's estimated $5 million PPV revenue — the first WrestleMania to achieve this milestone and the event that proved WrestleMania as a commercially viable annual PPV franchise. | 10 inches | Revenue Record Commemorative Plush | WWE Official Shop | $27.99 |
| 10 | WM2 Three-Commentator Team Record Plush Set Six Commentators Across Three Venues A commemorative plush set marking WM2's unique three separate commentary teams across three venues — McMahon/Saint James (NY), Monsoon/Okerlund/Crosby (Chicago), and Ventura/Hayes/Elvira (LA) — the most commentary teams ever used for a single WrestleMania broadcast. | Mini display | Broadcast Record Commemorative Set | WWE Official Shop | $39.99 |