| 1 | Diesel (Kevin Nash) WWF Champion — Retained vs. Shawn Michaels Diesel (Kevin Nash) was the WWF World Heavyweight Champion at WM11 — defending and retaining the title against Shawn Michaels in what is universally considered the best match of WrestleMania 11. | Also trained Lawrence Taylor for WM11 main event | Defending WWF Champion — Title Retention | Defeated Shawn Michaels to retain WWF Championship | WWE Hall of Famer 2015 (NWO) |
| 2 | Shawn Michaels Mr. WrestleMania — WM11 Title Shot Shawn Michaels (with Sycho Sid) earned his WWF Championship shot at WM11 by winning the Royal Rumble 1995 — losing to Diesel in the best match of the night despite Sycho Sid's interference. | — | WWF Title Challenger — Won Royal Rumble 1995 | Lost to Diesel (retained title) | WWE Hall of Famer 2011 — Mr. WrestleMania |
| 3 | Lawrence Taylor NFL Legend — WM Main Event Debut Lawrence Taylor — NFL Hall of Famer and New York Giants legend — made his in-ring wrestling debut at WM11 as the main event against Bam Bam Bigelow, winning with a forearm strike. | — | Celebrity Main Event Participant — In-Ring Debut | Defeated Bam Bam Bigelow | — |
| 4 | Bam Bam Bigelow Million Dollar Corporation — Main Event Loser Bam Bam Bigelow (managed by Ted DiBiase's Million Dollar Corporation) was the primary wrestling participant in WM11's celebrity main event — losing to Lawrence Taylor and subsequently being ejected from DiBiase's stable. | — | Celebrity Main Event Opponent — Million Dollar Corporatio... | Lost to Lawrence Taylor | — |
| 5 | Bret Hart The Hitman — I Quit Match vs. Backlund Bret Hart competed in the I Quit Match against Bob Backlund at WM11 — winning but in a controversial fashion when Roddy Piper stopped the match before Backlund actually said 'I Quit'. Hart himself considers this his worst career match. | — | I Quit Match Participant | Won — Piper stopped match (Backlund never said 'I Quit') | WWE Hall of Famer 2006 (three-time inductee) |
| 6 | Owen Hart Won WWF Tag Title with Mystery Partner Yokozuna Owen Hart finally won his first WWF championship at WM11 — teaming with mystery partner Yokozuna to defeat The Smoking Gunns for the WWF Tag Team Championship. | — | WWF Tag Championship Winner | Won tag titles with Yokozuna over Smoking Gunns | WWE Hall of Famer 2024 (posthumous) |
| 7 | The Undertaker Streak 4-0 — Defeated King Kong Bundy The Undertaker extended his WM streak to 4-0 at WM11 by defeating King Kong Bundy — with MLB umpire Larry Young as special referee during the baseball strike period. | — | WM Streak Extended 4-0 | Defeated King Kong Bundy | WWE Hall of Famer 2022 |
| 8 | Pamela Anderson Celebrity Manager/Escort — WM11's Biggest Celebrity Pamela Anderson — at the height of her Baywatch fame — was WM11's biggest celebrity guest, originally positioned as HBK's special escort before ending up with Diesel for the title celebration. | — | Celebrity Manager/Escort — WWF Championship Match | — | — |
| 9 | Roddy Piper Hot Rod — Special Referee for I Quit Match Rowdy Roddy Piper served as special referee for the Bret Hart vs. Bob Backlund I Quit Match at WM11 — stopping the match prematurely and preventing Backlund from saying 'I Quit', creating one of WM11's most discussed moments. | — | Special Referee — I Quit Match | — | WWE Hall of Famer 2005 |
| 10 | Razor Ramon (Scott Hall) The Bad Guy — IC Title DQ Loss Razor Ramon (with the 1-2-3 Kid) challenged for the WWF Intercontinental Championship against Jeff Jarrett at WM11 — winning via DQ but losing the championship on a technicality as titles don't change on DQ. | — | IC Title Challenger | Won by DQ — Jarrett retained IC title | WWE Hall of Famer 2014 (twice inducted) |